Friday, May 4, 2012

The Higher Price of Higher Education


Students, Your Loan Interest Rate Is About to Double


By Kayla Webley | Time Magazine Online, March 20, 2012

Prepare yourself: on July 1, as many as 8 million college students will see their interest rates on federally subsidized student loans double, from 3.4% to 6.8%. According to the U.S. Public Interest Research Group, that increase amounts to the average Stafford loan borrower’s paying $2,800 more over a standard 10-year repayment term for loans made after June 30.

It’s worse for those students who take out the most money. Those who borrow the maximum $23,000 in subsidized student loans will see their debt load upped by $5,000 over a 10-year repayment plan and $11,000 over a 20-year repayment plan.

With the deadline looming, college students last week delivered some 130,000 letters to Congress, urging legislators to keep the interest rate at 3.4%. Like many things in Washington this election year, the issue has become a partisan battle. President Obama and other Democrats have urged Congress to act to extend the low rate (Democrat Representative Joe Courtney of Connecticut has introduced legislation that would stop the rate hike), while Republicans favor allowing the rate to return to 6.8%. Even the cost estimates vary: Democrats predict that keeping the rate at 3.4% for one additional year would cost about $3 billion, while Republicans say it would cost nearly $7 billion. (Mark Kantrowitz of FinAid.org estimated the cost at $5.6 billion for one year.)

At the outset, doubling the interest rate seems like a really bad idea. The percentage of student loan borrowers in default is on the rise as student debt outpaces credit card debt. Students are already graduating with a record-high average debt of $25,000. And last year, for the first time ever, the total amount of student loans taken out topped $100 billion, and the total outstanding student loan debt is expected to top $1 trillion this year — also a first.

But the increase isn’t quite as devastating as it has been portrayed. To start, the 3.4% rate has been in effect only for one year. The rate decrease was passed by Congress in 2007 when Democratic legislators made good on campaign promises and passed the College Cost Reduction and Access Act. After the law passed, the interest rate on subsidized loans fell each year until reaching 3.4% this year — the same year it was set to expire.

Second, 6.8% is still a pretty low interest rate. Sure, 3.4% is better, but when compared with private student loans, which average 9% to 11%, and credit cards, which can have interest rates as high as 30%, 6.8% doesn’t sound all that alarming. (The interest rate for unsubsidized Stafford loans remains at 6.8%.)

The fact is, Congress is still dealing with a tight budget, and footing the bill for an interest-rate reduction is an expensive proposition. According to Kantrowitz, even in 2007, when the budget was more flush, legislators backpedaled on their campaign promises and cut the rate only on subsidized Stafford loans, rather than on all federal student loans, once they discovered how expensive it was to reduce the interest rate.

In the worst-case scenario, keeping the rate at 3.4% would create a vicious cycle. If the government put up the billions required to keep the rate low, they would likely be forced to turn elsewhere to tighten the belt. One of the potential targets, according to Kantrowitz, is the Pell grant, which is relied on by low-income students and has already sustained cuts. “Cutting Pell grants to maintain a low interest rate doesn’t make any sense,” Kantrowitz says. That’s because cutting grants would essentially force students to take out more loans, thus increasing their debt load. “If that happened, the government would essentially be taking away money from students with one hand and giving it back with another,” Kantrowitz says, adding that, in the end, allowing the interest rate on federally subsidized Stafford loans to return to 6.8% is the lesser of two evils.

62 comments:

  1. After reading the article, post a comment in which you claim the increases in interest rates as positive OR negative, offer evidence from the article to support the claim, and logically connect the evidence to the position. For example, "Raising interest rates for student loans is negative because it has the potential of establishing decades of monetary debt for the borrowers, which are basically kids trying to get a good education so that they can become positively contributing members of society."
    Once you have posted your comment, you are to reply to at least two other classmates’ original comments and one other classmate’s responses. If you do not complete this during class, you may do so for homework by 12:00 noon this Sunday, May 6.

    ReplyDelete
  2. I Dont Agree With This New Plan To Double Rates. Its Hard Enough For College Students To Afford Their College Tuition Now. Most Of Them Work Part Time Jobs And Go To College. I Think This Will Lead To More Dropouts.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. i agree with your statement , But why do you believe this will lead to more drop outs ?

      Delete
    2. I will agree with you because we will have a generation that will be less educated if they drop out, most will drop out because of stress and other problems.

      Delete
    3. Students Wont Be Able To Afford Their Tuition.

      Delete
    4. I agree that it will probably lead to more drop outs because of students not being able afford their tuition, and because of the stress it will cause them.

      Delete
    5. I like your point because about 78% of students in the US work and go to school to try and maintain college as it is now.

      Delete
    6. This comment has been removed by the author.

      Delete
    7. i completly agree because they are making it diffucult for students to keep their education by rasing prices witch will cause dropouts

      Delete
  3. I think making the intrest rate higher is negative. I think this because it's going to make it harder for people to get an education because they may not be able to afford it. By doing this people will probably end up going in debt for a long time because they might not be able to pay them off with them being so high.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I agree with you, the more students have to pay for their education, the more in debt they will be in.

      Delete
  4. The increase in intrest rates for an education is negative because students are having a hard time as it is trying to pay for college but now with this new increase its going to be much harder. I think the new increase in intrest may discourage many people to attend college and in this time college is important in order to get a decent job. Also the economy is really bad as it is so how are students who probably dont have really good jobs because they didn't attend college yet suppose to pay it? I think this may be happenening all over the world though because when I went to Montreal last month college students there were protesting because of the raise in prices for college. All over Montreal there were red boxes which were people against the idea and green which were people for the idea. There were many more red boxes then green. I think increasing the amount of money you have to pay for college is a really bad idea and just another example of how the government is unfair.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I agree with you kelsie because, as I have said the increase in interest will discourage many students to attend college. From your experience in Montreal, we can all see that this is starting to become a serious issue not only in our communities but worldwide as well.

      Delete
    2. You make a good point Steve because I thought that this was just happening in the US. Obviously I was wrong due to kelsie's observation in Montreal. And yeah it is a big issue because it's not only affecting the students but families as well.

      Delete
  5. The increase in interest rates is negative because people will have to pay more so it will take them longer to pay off their debt. Less people would want to go to college because of the longterm debt.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I agree with your point. This will cause many students hardships trying to get in to colleges, which will make less students interestead going.

      Delete
  6. I think that increasing the interest rate is a negative. Some people aren't as well off as others and if they go into debt they wont be able to pay it off. Also, people who are interested in going to college might see this and be turned off by it and end up not going to college.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I think this is a good statement but why do you think students may be turned off ?

      Delete
    2. (M)oney (I)s (A) (M)ajor (I)ssue .

      Delete
  7. I believe student loan increases is negative becase this is going to put millions of students into major debt. When you go to college you have to make the decision of how much money you would like to borrow or need to borrow in order to go to the college. Now many students may not even wnt to aim to going to good schools because of course they are more expensive and noone wants to borrow that much money if they intrest rates are going to sky rocket and cause these students to go into debt. The goverment should think about how many students are going to not want to go to school or more expensive schools before raising the intrest rate. The goverment needs to realize the major negative impact it will have on colleges, banks , and students.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. The government is a bunch of rich people telling the rest of the country what to do with their money. If you refuse to give it up (taxes, interest rates, consumerism), they will take it from you (law enforcment) one way or another. So, which is the better decision: to go into debt for the sake of education, or to try finding a decent-enough job to have a satisfying life?

      Delete
  8. I think that the increase in interest rates is a negative change. Raising interest rates for student loans is negative becuase this is raising the cost for a students education and only putting them in more debt that they are already going to be in. Raising the interest will only put the economy in more debt than they are already in becuase what if the students who borrowed money don't pay off there loans? It will only increase debt for the economy and for the students as well. I also think it will be a negative change because raising the cost will only dicourage many students to go to college and get an education.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I agree with you Steve because many students probably wont pay off there loans and then they might make the price of college even higher because they have students they have to pay for.

      Delete
    2. I 100% agree with you! Many people will probably get into so much debt because of this and wont pay it off.

      Delete
    3. Kelsie is right. Many students do not have all this money to pay off thier loans.

      Delete
    4. I agree. Lots of people don't want to go to college simply because they know it costs so much.I think you're right that the number of college students may decrease from the interest rates increasing.

      Delete
    5. I agree with you, I think this will make less people want to attend college because of how much they are going to have to borrow and pay back.

      Delete
    6. I agree with Kelsie with when she says that the interest rates will increase due to people not paying off their loans.

      Delete
    7. This makes perfect sense. Raising the interest rate will only put the wrong people in schools(people that can actually afford it and don't care about learning) and the people that actually try won't be able to get the education they deserve because they'll be in so much debt.

      Delete
  9. The increase interest rates are a big negative for the students. They will have to worry about more stuff when they are finish with college, everyone should be able to finish college and worry about their new job instead of the high interest rate that's going to benefit the government. The student might already have a debt and this increase in interest rate will cause more debt, people might not be able to pay it and they will have a bad credit score/ record for not being able to pay their student loan. It will be harder for people to get a house or a new car because of bad credit score.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I agree, I believe students shouldn't have to worry about how much debt they are in after colleage, but finding a job that insterests them and makes them happy.

      Delete
  10. I think that doubling the interest rates for student loans is negative because even now there are college graduates in their 30s who are still in a lot of debt. If these amounts increase significantly then people may be in debt well into their 40s or, depending on how many years they go to school, possibly into their 50s.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I Dont Know About Most People But I Dont Want To Be Working When Im 50 years old. I Would Want To Be Retired By Then.

      Delete
    2. I agree with you and who would want to go to college if they aren't going to be able to enjoy life and have a little extra money to do fun activities that they enjoy because they have to pay off their debt.

      Delete
    3. I agree Rachel. There is no reason for a higher interest rate for a student loan. No one wants to pay that much money when they can simply get a job that pays less but it still gets them everything the need for their daily life.

      Delete
    4. I agree Samantha, they should worry about their life and thier family instead of paying off a loan.

      Delete
    5. I agree Sam. Education is important to get a higher salary but if a lot of your money is going back to the government, from all kinds of taxes not just education, then there is nothing left for people to live on.

      Delete
    6. That is a good point too. People will have no money.

      Delete
  11. Raising Student loans is negative because students will be graduating from college while being in debt at an estimated $25,000. But if they dont't raise student loans the government will be forced to cut the Pell grants for low income students. Cutting the grants will just force students to take out even more loans which will still leave them in debt either way. Basically that would just be like they're taking away the money and just giving it right back, what's the point of that? These kids are just trying to have a good education so they're life can be easier when they graduate and get a good job. And leaving these kids in debt way after college is still ridiculous. The government is already in debt, why would it make sence to make all these students be in debt. I mean what if these kids cant repay all their loans, is the governtment going to keep raising the interest rate? Raising the insterest rate does not make sence at all. It will just cause a bigger problem. If they want these students to stay in school and get a good education I suggest that hey leave the interest rate as is. It would help nothing if they raised it.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. That is a good point about how if the government cuts pell grants, then students will just be in debt anyway.

      Delete
  12. I believe the interest increase is ridiculous. Its not right to do this to students the economy is making it so it is hard to get a job without a college degree but now if you go to college you have to pay so much that you will pretty much be in debt due to loans. It is almost better to not go to college now. If you take the average loan of 23000 then you have to pay 5000 on the ten year plan. That is alot of profit for the bank especially because there are so many students taking out loans. Its ridiculous the amount of money they are making. All it is doing is making the economy worse and worse.

    ReplyDelete
  13. The increase in interest rates is negative. It is negative because the increase will cause students to owe more money to the loaners they get money from. Instead of paying 3.4% interest back, the government is increasing it to 6.8% which is a huge change. This sudden change can cause alot of students to go into debt, which is not good at all.

    ReplyDelete
  14. An increase in interest rates is obviously both positive and negative. Negative for the students and positive for the government. The students would be put in dept for several years and mind you, these students are our next generation of proffessions or what ever in our future. Meanwhile the government will be getting the money and making use of it. I think that the rates should be a little lower ranging between 3.4% to 6.8% , probably like 4.7 so that its fair.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I agree with that if they were going to raise the interest rate then they should raise it to something lower the 6.8. That is to much for people to handle and its ridiculous that people should have to pay that much just to go to school. It makes people not want to go to school.

      Delete
  15. increaseing the rate are negative because no one would be able to afford it and people will not want to go to college. america is already in a national debt, we already pay enogh taxes for that now we wil pay more

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. If there are increased interest rates then that means there will be more money for financial help, which will benefit the students more. They will have more opportunity to get help.

      Delete
  16. The increase in intrest of the student loans makes sense, since it would obviously cost more to keep the loans at the 3.4% rate and a one year extension wouldn't make that much of difference. Although the Democrats claim that it would cost $3Billion for the extention and the Republicans disagree, with the claim that the extension would cost $7Billion. Keeping the 3.4% seems like a worthless change due the cost and the amount of indivisuals that would actually pay it off before the end of the year. Overall, the increases in the rates of Stafford loans is more positive than negative. At the end of the day DON'T BORROW WHAT YOU CAN'T PAY BACK!! -YOLO

    ReplyDelete
  17. i think the increase in interest rates is negative because its costing people more money for their education. I personally think if the cost is to expensive for some people and their families to afford, it will result in more people not going to college and having a lower chance of getting a job later in life to support yourself. i know alot of people today that have been out of college for a signifficent amount of time and is still paying off their debts. If the amount of interest increase people will most likely b epaying of debt for a very long time.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I agree that it will result in less people going to college and that it will be harder for people to get a job because of that. People will say its to much and just not go to college.

      Delete
  18. As a student going into college in only two years, I should probably take the opposing side to increased interest rates. But I can't help but think that there might be some good to this. It might make people try harder to pay off their debts more quickly. Even though debt and loans are growing, sometimes you have to be pushed to the edge to really change. And, as one paragraph says, it really is only 6.8%. 68 dollars for every thousand that you borrow and don't pay on time. How is that different from library fees, or car payments, or bills in general? Also, who wants the government to have to cut something different, like financial aid or something we really depend on? That could happen if they spend the money on keeping interest rates lower. It is far better in the long run to give a little in one area then to give a lot in another.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. i disagree because i dont think it will make them try harder but more of give up faster. syain forget this i dont need college anyways because i have my degree

      Delete
  19. Increasing the interest rate for a student loan is a negative thing and it can be a positive thing. Personally, I don't think it should be raised though. Sure it'll help the government out a little but then they'll get more money by raising the interest rate for something else. I feel like an education should be free no matter how old you are or what school you go to. It's not right for someone that wants to make society a better place, working somewhere really important if they have to spend the rest of their life in debt because of how they got there. A higher interest rate for a student loan is just ridiculous.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I agree that it's going to help the government a little, but it's not going to pay off the Nation Debt.

      Delete
    2. You're absolutely right! And yeah it's helping the government out but my opinion - this shouldn't even be about helping the government out. The point of coming up with new plans is to help society and make things just a little bit easier on us.

      Delete
    3. I agree, increasing the rate for a student loan is ridiculous, nobody wants to spend years after they graduating paying off their debt.

      Delete
  20. I think that doubling the loan interest rate is negative. The reason - because students or new comers to college are not going to support the idea. If there’s no one to support this plan then it’s going to fail. As stated in the article - "With the deadline looming, college students last week delivered some 130,000 letters to Congress, urging legislators to keep the interest rate at 3.4%", we have seen how negatively students are reacting. Point is students with potential are eventually going to drop out of school only because they have to pay so much for their education, which isn't fair at all.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. You're right. Many college students are angry about this now when it's only just begun. I don't know how the government thinks this will help anything.

      Delete
  21. After reading this, I've come to a conclusion that this would be beneficial in the long run to come. But yet the increase will still have an impact on students trying to sign up for college, most people that have it hard to afford might not even go because of the cost.

    ReplyDelete
  22. loans. that is basicaly puttin a price on education. this i s money som e students dont have or have difucatly paying back.this can interfer with school work tryin to get extra money by working more to pay back.it affects life afte you are finished with school because you could be stugguling to be independent or housing your self with the thoughts of you still have to pay back dubble of what you owe like what you owed wasnt enough

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I agree with you jasmine, nobody would want to be in that much debt after they graduated.

      Delete
  23. I don't agree with doubling the interest rates and I think this is negative because it's already hard enough now for kids to afford college, if they increased it kids would not even try anymore or just dropout. They would have to be paying it off years after they graduated.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I agree. A lot of kids in high school aren't considering college as an option because of how much it costs, if that cost goes up then even more kids won't want to go to college.

      Delete