Read the TimesUnion.com article below, then post a comment in which you claim the Promise will be successful or unsuccessful, offer evidence from the article as well as outside information to support your claim, and logically connect the evidence to your position.
Once you have posted a comment, you are to reply to at least three other classmates’ original comments and one other classmate’s responses. Students that do not complete this during class may do so for homework by 9:00 PM on Tuesday, May 8, 2012.
A Promise for Better Futures
Albany Promise to announce major initiative for children attending the poorest schools
By Scott Waldman
Published 11:25 p.m., Sunday, May 6, 2012
ALBANY — The odds are stacked against them the day they are born.
The children who live in Albany's poorest neighborhoods are less likely to meet basic academic standards in English and math, less likely to finish high school and college, and less likely to pass their Regents exams.
They are more likely to become pregnant teenagers, more likely to miss school for unexcused absences, incarceration or suspension, and more likely to feel suicidal, according a report by a new educational consortium.
On Monday, the partnership, which is made up of 60 different stakeholders, will announce a major new effort to turn around the educational outcomes for the poorest children in Albany. Years in the making, it will target children in Arbor Hill, West Hill and the South End. The Albany Promise, as the group is calling itself, will draw on existing resources and a bundling of private donations, as well as state and federal grants, to help poor children receive the same opportunities in and out of school as their middle- and upper-class counterparts do.
Partners include the Albany school district, the city, the State University of New York, The College of Saint Rose, and many area nonprofits and businesses.
"We are going to work together to make sure every child, every step of the way, experiences success and nobody is left out," SUNY Chancellor Nancy Zimpher said.
She said Promise recognizes that this is a monumental task, one too vast to be accomplished by any one entity.
The Albany effort is partially modeled on Project Strive, a cradle-to-career effort Zimpher helped create that has expanded to sites around the country, and the Harlem Children's Zone, a New York City initiative that provides education as well as social and health services for children from birth until they enter the workforce. SUNY will create similar initiatives in other cities across the state.
The neighborhoods targeted by the new effort are the places in Albany where plywood covers many windows, where businesses have fled and where children are in need of a brighter future. They are not just at the epicenter of the city's poverty; they are also home to 9,000 children under age 18, including 2,500 under age 5, according to the new report produced by the consortium.
And the challenges faced by children in the city's poorest neighborhoods are profound. A quarter of Albany's children under 5 live in poverty, but in the neighborhoods targeted by the new effort, that number climbs to 60 percent, the report states.
The program is open to all children and families in the affected neighborhoods, regardless of where they attend school. Goals will be to prepare children for kindergarten, competency in core subjects, transition to high school, graduation from high school and entry into college or the workforce.
The goal is to create a pipeline of support for kids, mostly through uniting existing agencies, said Linda Jackson-Chalmers, assistant superintendent for community relations for Albany schools.
"It's a concept in order to support students in a successful life and career, it takes a whole village," she said.
Albany Promise will cost $500,000 to $750,000 annually and will eventually be housed at the Trinity Institute headquarters. The consortium has already raised $200,000 from private and corporate donors, including SEFCU and Turner Construction.
The first step will be to unite the city's diverse array of existing afterschool programs by bringing in leaders to decide on a narrow focus and common set of goals. Transportation will also be expanded to broaden participation by children in existing programs. There will also be more outreach to those who will be affected by the effort, said Barbara Smith, city councilwoman and a co-founder of the Albany Family Education Alliance.
Inspired by the Harlem Children's Zone, Smith and other concerned citizens and parents created a Baby Institute, where expectant mothers are prepared for the birth of their first child, and an after-school program focused on literacy.
"It's clear that fixing education and improving outcomes is not a simple proposition," she said. "It's very complex. We need different kinds of expertise focused on different aspects."
Smith said one of the priorities of the new effort will be getting input and participation from those who live in the affected neighborhoods. She said the Promise effort wants to create summer learning activities and access to extracurriculars that wealthier children experience throughout their school years.
Monday's announcement will include leaders in education, community, business, government and philanthropy and will be held from 9 to 11 a.m. at Giffen Memorial Elementary School. A second launch event will be held from 6 to 8 p.m. at Albany High School.
I think the promise will be successful. The albany government has a strong plan. The cost for the project is almost payed for. So the government is on a good track to acomplish the promise. The promise will give children in albany that live in poverty a chance to go to school and get a good education. The high school graduation rates could increase. So people from albany would have a better chance to go to college and get decent jobs.
ReplyDeleteI don't agree with you because even though Albany has a strong plan it doesn't mean it will be succesful. Through the years there have been many strong plans to try and change graduation rate but none have worked.
DeleteI agree with you Kelsie. I believe that no matter what people do to the schools it will not change anything because of the way the life is outside of school.
DeleteI agree with Kelsie many people and plans have been brought about to try to change albany, what makes you think this plan will actually be different and work?
DeleteKelsie have mentioned that there have been many strong plans, what were those plans?
Deletei disagree with kelsie because once kids realize that their future are at risk they will want to change.
DeleteAmit, almost all the changes they make to our schools are to try and get graduation rates to raise and they still haven't. Carlos, they have had many different assemblies to try inform and warn students about their futures, but how many students can we say actually listened to them and changed? Also I think most of us are aware of what the future has to hold for us but what we do with that information is up to us and random people aren't going to change our minds.
DeleteI see what your trying to say Kelsie. It is the kids choice to do well in school, if the kids aren't determined to do there best, then they won't get any better chances of graduating. Alot of kids in those areas of Albany just don't care about school because alot of their parents don't care about it. I think this program needs to work on helping the parents be role models for their kids, which will in turn inpire their kids to do well in school and make good choices.
DeleteI am inbetween on if this promise will be sucessful. Albany school district is about 25 minutes away from the school district i reside in, Schenectady. Albany and schenectady have similar problems relating to poverty, pregnancy, and drop outs. Over the past couple years the nys goverment has tried to fund schenectady and help our school and community change its ways. In my opinion i see no difference. In schenectady pregnancy rates among teens have risen, we still have the same drop out rate, and poverty is major. Even though albany is a different ploace than schenectady i believe things will most likley stay the same as they did in schenectady.
ReplyDeleteI agree with you that Schenectady had no change and that Albany will be the same way.
DeleteI agree with you Zach nothing will ever change for our school districts.
DeleteIt's true that there most likely won't be any change from this but there is still that very slim chance that Albany could improve in ways that Schenectady hasn't yet.
DeleteI agree Demani, Schenectady and Albany school district have similar problems. If they keep going down and get worst both districts will have more attention from the media, just like the attention Schenectady got, pregnancy rates among teens have risen.
DeleteTheres a possibility that the plan will be successful but I doubt it because there has been many attempts to try and fix inner city school districts and none have worked yet. I think that the way districts like Albany, Schenectady and Troy are now is probably how they will always be because it has to be the students that want the change not the adults who want to make the change for them. I think Albany has a better plan than Schenectady's plan for next year to increase graduation rate, but I dont think it will work.
ReplyDeleteI agree with you Kelsie because, there have been many attempts to try and fix school district issues and it has to be the students that has to want to make a change.
DeleteYou're absolutely right kels because the kids are the ones that are suppose to want to make a better future for themselves. The adults can be there and tag along but the can't make the change for the kids.
DeleteThis comment has been removed by the author.
DeleteI said I dont think the plan will work.
Deletei think promise will be successful. i believe if they get more people to help out they will be very strong in helping out the kids. i think all cities should have something like this. that way our education level in america could increase.
ReplyDeleteHow will the community get more people to help out? , when it is the people in the community that need change. I believe we need people outside of the community to help Albany come back on top.
DeleteI agree Damani, because it is the kids that needs to change and make a better future for themselves but they can't do that unless they have good committed members within the organization.
DeleteI do not think this will be successful. I believe the schools are the way they are and they will remain that way until the children change. I believe that all the things will remian the same like; how they are liekly not to finish highschool or college , fail the regents exams , more likely to become pregnant s teenagers and more likely to miss school for un exused absences. I believe that these things have nothing to do with the school it has alot to do with the way the kids are raised and the people they are brought up around. Once the school has the chance to change the kids its to late. I believe people need to do mroe things about home life. Thats the reason why the kids are the way they are.
ReplyDeleteI agree with you. I believe that you can not change a community that dosent want to be changed and that is how i feel Albany is.
DeleteI agree with you, they should start trying to change students earlier in life so maybe students will have goals and make the right choices.
DeleteI agree with you although I said the promise would be successful. Its true that its the way the kids act and all. But the government isnt gunna change their own home lives cus I think that would be an invasion of privacy? Schools could set up programs and stuff like that to change the way the kids think and or act and could motivate them to do better in school.
DeleteI agree with you. I don't see how this promise will change anything. It's how they were raised and how they see the world. It starts at home and those students cary that behavior to school and to other places that they go.
Deletei disagree with you Zach because the government can not change wat you do at your house or how you are raised. They can change how you learn and what you learn.
DeleteI agree, things will remain the same until the children change. Nothing is going to change unless the kids do and thats what people don't understand.
DeleteI think the promise will be successful. The government is doing well so far.It obviously will take some time but I think there will be a very positive outcome. Albany people would get a better education and have a greater chance of being successful in there own lives.
ReplyDeleteI think time is not on our side. By the time this promise takes effect, How bad do you think the community will be? It will probably be to damaged to fix.
DeleteYeah true I agree.. I just wrote that. I really dont care honestly. Its not a promise for schenectady
DeleteThis comment has been removed by the author.
ReplyDeleteI agree with you Sam, it is a complete waste of money and time. People are going to do what they want to do even if people try to help them.
DeleteI'm not really sure if the promise will be successful. There are other cities that are just like Albany, like Schenectady and others that worse. I'm not sure why the government is so focused on Albany, if Albany and Schenectady both have the same problems with pregnant teens, skipping school, suspension and suicide. It's a good idea, but you can't just expect the students will change because of it.
ReplyDeleteExactly. Other schools have the same problem and they probably didn't get any help from the government. I don't know why the government are so fixed on Albany. If the students aren't willing to change then I don't think they'll change with help.
DeleteYou're right. The state can't just expect kids to change right away. Some kids may not change at all, so the plan is going to have to be prepared for that kind of response.
DeleteExactly Sam, There are other cities that need the help so much more than Albany, but the government is so focused on them.
DeleteI think that this attempt to make a change the society of Albany will not be successful. I think it will not be successful because the 'Partnership' who is trying to make the change can't just come in and tell people what to do. I also think that the students in Albany will refuse to cooperate and work with the 'Partnership' because they are used to doing things there way for many years and some students just don't care. In relation to the students in Albany, there are many students here in Schenectady that face the same issues and people try to make a change and students just don't care.
ReplyDeleteI agree Steve because these students have been living this way for a long time now why would they all of a sudden listen to random people to change.
DeleteI agree people are not going to want to change something they are use to.
DeleteI agree, students dont even listen to people they know what makes them think that they're going to listen to people they dont know.
DeleteAgreed Steve, some kids just don't care about their education and this program may just be another fail BUT what about those kids that do want to change their lives? They have an oppportunity now to try and make a better future for themselves.
DeleteI'm unsure if this plan will be successful right away because of the number of problems that Albany has, with both poverty and schooling. The education issues have become so bad that the Albany school district has been added to the state watch list. But if the city and the people in it are willing to keep this plan going then some good can come from it. If they give up too soon then it will just be a waste of money and a failed attempt at change.
ReplyDeleteI agree with you that the students and people living in Albany have to be willing to do this program. If they don't, itll just be a waste of money and time that could've been used for some other district.
DeleteI want this plan to work because it has the potential to really help Albany but the odds aren't in their favor. They will most likely give up too soon, before the plan even has a chance to really start to show any improvement.
DeleteI agree with you that it could be a waste of money because they can't just expect the kids to change right away.
DeleteI do not think this promise will be successful. I believe if students wanted to go to school they would. Most teenagers dont have the drive to go to school and get an education. Its not the schools that need to change, its the students that need to. A lot of kids dont have a good home life and that can effect a childs success in life.
ReplyDeleteI agree with you Danaysha that it's the students that need to change if they want to make a difference, not the school. You also mention that things that go on outside of school can have a effect on them, that's a great point.
DeleteThis plan to help improve Albany school district by giving the poorest kids money so they can afford it might not work. I think it will not work because the government have giving us money already to help us improve our district in Schenectady and it didn’t work. The graduation rate is still low, many are still dropping out and many are still getting into trouble. Albany school district is almost the same as Schenectady school district. If they are going to change it they should have a stronger and better plan.
ReplyDeleteThe Schenectady School District and the Albany School District do have a lot in common but you can't automatically assume they will have the same results. If everyone puts in enough effort then maybe the plan could work.
DeleteI think the promise may be successful. I think if they have enough people become a part of it they will be able to make a change. But I also feel like it could be un-successful because of how many teen pregnancies and how many drop outs there already is. And I believe a lot of kids will still end up doing what they want anyway.
ReplyDeleteI agree with you that the Promise need people to help tham if they want to make a change. If they have the people to help out with the program it might be successful.
DeleteI believe that the promise is on the right track in supporting these "troubled" kids. As stated in the article "The children who live in Albany's poorest neighborhoods are less likely to meet basic academic standards in English and math, less likely to finish high school and college, and less likely to pass their Regents exams.", are all facts but not if the promise can decrease this rate by helping them. I strongly think that the promise is going to be successful if they have committed members within the organization. Maybe this will open the eyes of these kids that need help and actually want to help themselves.
ReplyDeleteMaryann, I strongly disagree with you becuase what if this "promise" is not fullfilled? What will all the organization say to all of the supporters then ?
DeleteI honestly think this program will be a waste of money. It's the students choice to learn and if they don't want to learn, you can't force them to. Students drop out because of their own reasons. Schenectady has the some of the same issues and I haven't heard anything about people trying to help Schenectady. Sure there are some kids that can't go to school but spending 500,000 to 750,000 annually is ridiculous. Also teenagers don't have to get pregnant at an age where they can't even take care of themselves all the time and if something does happen they always have the right to go back to school after. This promise is most likely going to fail in my eyes.
ReplyDeleteI agree with you Sam, it is a waste of moeny and time. People are going to do what they want even if you try and help them.
DeleteI agree. It is a lot of money to be spending per year. If Albany decides to follow through on this plan, it had better work.
DeleteI agree with you sam, just because of the promise they can't expect kids to learn,if they don't want too. It will be a waste of money.
DeleteI agree as well just because they promise something doesnt mean will fall through with thier promise.
DeleteI doubt the sucess of this promise. I beleive the kids under the age of 12 are more likely to be positively affected by this plan. Highschool kids are not likely to gain sucess unless they are comepletely willing to do so. Poverty is a major issue but the countless times that government has tryed to change school systems to help students and failed makes me question the outcome of this plan.
ReplyDeleteI agree with you about the fact that younger kids will be affected because you can still change them, but by the time the kids reach highschool they are not going to change anything about the way they are.
Deleteexcuse my spelling.
DeleteThere has beeen similiar plans just like this one and aren't guaranteed to work. But these plans fail all because of the amount of commitment. And you are right because we can't blame this one on the governmant because they have tried MULTIPLE TIMES!
Deletei agree with you about younger kids, but its not just high schoolers anymore the levels or caring about school education is getting lower and lower by the year. in about 5 years or less 12 year old kids will be doin what they want in the streest with nobody stoping them because they are so emotionaly and physicaly torn by there poverty that school has now become forgen
DeleteI do believe that The Albany Promise program will be successful. It seems that the government and all the corporations and privately owned businesses are working hard to get this program up and running. All children, wheather they live in poverty or not, should have the same opportunity as the middle class and upper class kids to have a chance to go to school and get an education. BUT, is it worth putting all this effort into a program that might not work? I mean what if these kids dont want to go to school an get a proper education, why waste time and money to put together a program that will go down the drain in the end? Take a look at our school district, Schenectady County School District. Look at how many kids skip school and all the kids that drop out. Look at all the kids that end up falling asleep in class because they were to busy texting all night or playing video games. I mean look at the kids that do come to school but end up failing anyways because they dont do their work. They're all getting the chance to have a good education and they're throwing it all away. They're not realizing that there are many other kids out there that don't have the opportunity that they do to go to school and to learn. These are all things that need to be put into perspective before people go around throwing money into a program that will be useless. I mean yes their will be kids that will definietly take advantage of this program to make their life better, but there will also be kids that think its a joke and not even think twice about how good this program can be for them. Giving kids the opportunity to get an education is an amazing thing to do. But is it what they want? Or is this whole thing pointless...? Good luck on The Albany Promise program, hopefully it works out for the best.
ReplyDeleteI agree that this rpogram might not be a success. Like i said in my post, it is a lot of money. And i also agree that kids just don't care sometimes. It can be really hard to make them understand how important education really is.
DeleteI believe that the promise is on the right track in supporting these "troubled" children. This has been an on going problem for many of years. I dont think will do any good because you cant control what kids after school only during school. Only a small percentage of these children will accutally listen. Where as others will do what ever they want to.
ReplyDeletei agree most kids do what they want instead of doin whats right to better themselves, but that small pecentage that will go set a great example for other kids out there
DeleteI believe that this program will be successful. The Albany Promise has many things planned in order to improve the education of the kids in Albany. It is smart they are trying to get the afterschool programs to come together because if kids have somewhere to go after school, they are less likely to get in trouble. I also know this will work because, in the article, it talked about the Albany Promise making programs to make the transition to high school easier. The Schenectady school district did something like that and it worked out great because it made freshmen year much easier.
ReplyDeletei agree this can keep them out of drugs , gangs , and pregnacy. help them stay educated and occupied instead of running the streets after school
Deletethe after school programs are really important because maybe kids who don't want to go home will have more of a support system.
DeleteI agree with Gillian. Most of the teens do the things they do because they have nothing else better to do.
DeleteThis comment has been removed by the author.
ReplyDeleteThis comment has been removed by the author.
ReplyDeleteFrom reading this article, i'm positive that this promise will be succesful. This is a great cause to help the kids of Albany that have less in life and that society look as, as worth less to get them on their feets and make it somewhere in society while experience success . With such a great cause i'm sure more money will be coming in to help support it. This will lead the Albany society to a much brighter future for all it's resadence.
ReplyDeletei beleive the promis will succeed. it is a great cause tryin to keep kids in school and help them graduate.helping keepin kids educated and out of the streets because they are too poor to stay in school,can keep kids out of gangs and pregnacy and as far away from drugs as possiable
ReplyDeleteI think that that is the most important part; keeping kids out of the badness that is in the world.
DeleteI agree with you that it's a good cause, but what if its just a waste of money because the kids don't change? They can't make the kids learn if they don't want too.
DeleteI Think The Promise Will Suceed Because its a growing problem that effects alot of teens
DeleteI think that there is a very good chance that this project could succeed. With 60 stakeholders and a couple of companies funding it, it will have enough money to get what it needs done. However, sometimes people tend to get their hopes up as far as what they can get done with the resources they have. It will cost 500,000 to 750,000 dollars annually, which is a lot of money. Even with Sefcu and Turner construction sponsoring the promise project, it still might be difficult to get the money needed. But I do think that it is well worth it. Especially because of the issues that are in these areas of Albany. It isn't just school either. According to the National Runaway Switchboard, between 1.3 and 2.8 million teens are on the run from their home life every single day. There are certain issues to be addressed like abuse at home that this program might be able to help with, because these are probably the problems that are the reasons for the failure in school.
ReplyDelete